MDJunction - People Helping People
 

Why wear a ribbon?

 
"For my husband" (Jeanbean8)

MDJunction to me

Sylvia4648"I have suffered from depression most of my life, but had some long, non-depressed times. The last 16 years have been an on-going, constantly worsening nightmare for me medically, socially and with my family. 11/2008 to the present has been the worst time in my life, and new things just keep piling up. During that time I’ve gone from being mostly homebound to being totally homebound due to the errors of about 2 dozen doctors who overmedicated me so badly that I came home w/ 4 conditions I didn’t go in with. I spent months wanting to die, and finding MDJ may well have saved my life. It’s one of the worst feelings to know that nobody on earth needs you for anything; but now that I’ve been a group leader for awhile, there are people here who need me. Thanks MDJ." (Sylvia4648)

more testimonials
Lyme Disease Support Group
A community of patients, family members and friends dedicated to dealing with lyme disease, together.
Join This Group
Group Home   Forums   Articles   Members (7836)   Diaries   Leaders   Guidelines
Lyme Group RSS Feed
Lyme Disease ForumsMedicine & Treatmentscost of lab tests: ELISA vs Western Blot
05/04/2012 07:47 AM
prillo
Posts: 39
New Member

Hello everyone,

I noticed in reading about Lyme that doctors traditionally prefer to do the ELISA lab test, and if it's positive, then do the Western Blot.

I understood that this was because the ELISA is less expensive. But the Western Blot is more accurate, so why not do it first, right?

I called for costs at our local hospital, and the ELISA for Lyme is $340, while the Western Blot for Lyme is $104.

So in this case, the ELISA is *not* less expensive. One more reason to skip it. Just FYI for anybody in the same boat.

BTW lab results are not back yet for me, but I am waiting...

Reply

05/04/2012 08:45 AM  Top
pampe
pampe
 
Posts: 1262
Group Leader

I would not suggest having a WB done at your local hospital.

Igenex Lab or Quest are the premier test sights. I cannot imagine why an Elisa would be cheaper actually.

Are you sure you don't have them reversed?

Pam
Group Leader

(I am not a doctor. I am not involved with insurance or the government. Any advice I give is purely from my own experience and/or research. Always discuss your healthcare concerns with an appropriate medical professional.)
~~
2003 BB IGG/IGM + (told it was negative)
~~
May, 2012 IgeneX (CDC positive)
~~~~
MTHFR= homozygous A1298C
~~~~~~
October 2012 WB Igenex CDC Positive
~~~~~
Last WB (2/2013):
CDC positive
~~~
My story can be found on the Group Leaders page.

05/04/2012 08:48 AM  Top
prillo
Posts: 39
New Member

Thanks pampe. I did not know this about where to test. The labs are already done at the hospital.

Because I still have symptoms (tick bite was early March) I have scheduled an appointment regardless of the lab results.

Perhaps they will schedule another lab with Igenex or Quest? I will ask.

Meantime I double-checked and the ELISA is indeed $340 and Western Blot $104. Can you educate me and let me know why the ELISA would make sense to be more expensive?

I am so new to this... knowledge is power. Smile

Thank you again!

Post edited by: prillo, at: 05/05/2012 11:24 AM


05/04/2012 08:08 PM  Top
WiscLamLymie
WiscLamLymie
 
Posts: 1325
Group Leader

Here is the reason why the ELISA is run first and nearly exclusively:

The man who holds the patent is still an active member of... (brain foggy today) I believe the IDSA or CDC. Can't remember which.

But basically he is the one getting the royalties for this test being run and he's still a big player in the game of "pull the wool over the general public and doctors' eyes and let the Lymies rot."

Wow. That sounds REALLY harsh. LOL Sorry folks. It just is very upsetting to me to know that truth and that is one reason why SO many are being undiagnosed and misdiagnosed, including myself for over a year (which is NOTHING compared to many of you out there!!).

So there's the ugly truth. Nothing more than $$$$$$$$$.

Sad Lauren

Was diagnosed with Autonomic Disorder, POTS, Interstitial Cystitis, and Fibromyalgia. True story is I have late stage Lyme which has caused these things. Just began the fight in October 2011 (have been full-blown Lyme since Sept. 5, 2010), and WILL be victorious! Positive bands: IgG 41 and 60; IgM 23 and 41. CDC positive!

Not a doctor, not anyone of any legal standing... just someone on the search.
(Translation: Please do not take anything I say as medical advice. Always see your doctor when needing medical advice.)

05/04/2012 08:18 PM  Top
Klipper
 
Posts: 44
Member

Lauren! Where did you locate this information? Uhg!! <pulling my hair out>
Klipper

05/04/2012 09:28 PM  Top
nank59
nank59
 
Posts: 803
Member

The cost of my ELISA was $225 at a local lab - where, by the way, the one man running the show remarked that "Oh, it's probably just an allergic reaction to something, we'll get this taken care of."

The cost of my WB was $260 through IGenex - plus $25 to the local lab (different lab from the one man show lab).

Post edited by: nank59, at: 05/04/2012 09:31 PM

nan

I am not a doctor, nor have I ever been. All comments are based on my personal experience or opinion.

IgM
41+

IgG
41+
31 IND
39 IND

Currently treating Lyme & Babesiosis.
Have many Bart symptoms.

Blessings! :)

05/05/2012 11:26 AM  Top
prillo
Posts: 39
New Member

nank59, that is interesting. It's backward here. Then again, labs were nearly twice as much from one lab to the next when I called to compare.

I would be glad to pay more if I knew the results would be more accurate, but did not know Igenex/Quest was somehow better then. I haven't called either of them yet.


05/05/2012 01:01 PM  Top
pampe
pampe
 
Posts: 1262
Group Leader

prillo, the Igenex website has everything you need including downloadable forms.
Pam
Group Leader

(I am not a doctor. I am not involved with insurance or the government. Any advice I give is purely from my own experience and/or research. Always discuss your healthcare concerns with an appropriate medical professional.)
~~
2003 BB IGG/IGM + (told it was negative)
~~
May, 2012 IgeneX (CDC positive)
~~~~
MTHFR= homozygous A1298C
~~~~~~
October 2012 WB Igenex CDC Positive
~~~~~
Last WB (2/2013):
CDC positive
~~~
My story can be found on the Group Leaders page.

05/05/2012 03:39 PM  Top
Bettyg
 
Posts: 26593
VIP Member
I'm an Advocate

lauren,

are you thinking of WORMSER OR STEERE?| those 2 are the top 2 players for idsa/infectious drs. and proclaiming protein bands 31 adn 34 lyme specific will NOT be included in western blot igm/igg???

Here is the reason why the ELISA is run first and nearly exclusively:

The man who holds the patent is still an active member of... (brain foggy today) I believe the IDSA or CDC. Can't remember which.

But basically he is the one getting the royalties for this test being run and he's still a big player in the game of "pull the wool over the general public and doctors' eyes and let the Lymies rot."

bettyg, IOWA ACTIVIST FOREVER Wink

BettyG, IOWA ACTIVIST
RETIRED llmd coordinator of 6 yrs; group leader

NOTE: I DO "NOT" USE CHAT thanks!
**************************************

NO INFORMATION SHOULD BE CONSIDERED MEDICAL ADVICE.
please see my WELCOME LETTER/BEGINNER'S LINKS with important links/info galore :)

http://www.mdjunction.com/forums/lyme-disease-support-forums/general-support/2356916-bettygs-welcome-letter-wgood-beginner-links-

Any information provided should not be used to take the place of advice from your personal physician or other professional.

Information on those sites is the opinion of those who publish the sites and is NOT necessarily that of BettyG.

43 yrs. chronic lyme; 35 yrs. misdiagnosed by 40-50 drs. unacceptable; see my profile for more.

05/08/2012 06:44 AM  Top
WiscLamLymie
WiscLamLymie
 
Posts: 1325
Group Leader

It's definitely an IDSA member. Can't find who right now, but that is a fact. IDSA member.
Was diagnosed with Autonomic Disorder, POTS, Interstitial Cystitis, and Fibromyalgia. True story is I have late stage Lyme which has caused these things. Just began the fight in October 2011 (have been full-blown Lyme since Sept. 5, 2010), and WILL be victorious! Positive bands: IgG 41 and 60; IgM 23 and 41. CDC positive!

Not a doctor, not anyone of any legal standing... just someone on the search.
(Translation: Please do not take anything I say as medical advice. Always see your doctor when needing medical advice.)
Reply

Share this discussion with your friends:
Members who viewed this page also read:

LymeLyme Disease ForumsMedicine & Treatmentscost of lab tests: ELISA vs Western Blot

Disclaimer: The information provided in MDJunction is not a replacement for medical diagnosis, treatment, or professional medical advice.
In case of EMERGENCY call 911 or 1.800.273.TALK (8255) to the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline. Read more.
Contact Us | Bookmark Us | FAQ | Awareness Ribbons
About Us | Terms & Conditions | Privacy | Spread the Word | MDJ Advocates | Advertise
Copyright (c) 2006-2013 MDJunction.com All Rights Reserved