MDJunction - People Helping People
 

Why wear a ribbon?

 
"Lyme Disease" (Tbic)

MDJunction to me

ThereseML"When I first came to MDJ, I was in need of peer support in dealing with issues of my childhood abuse. I was moving away from the painful issues and trying to find an uplifting group of people to help me transition to a thriver in my life. I found that here. I also found a group of peers with Fibromyalgia and found the same uplifting experience there. My computer crashed and it was a while before I found my way back, this time with issues related to Parkinson's Disease. I had tried a few other support sites before reminding myself of MDJ. On those, I never got a reply. I finally found my way back here and again found very supportive, caring and inspiring people who made me feel like I was 'back home'. Indeed I am." (ThereseML)

more testimonials
Lyme Disease Support Group
A community of patients, family members and friends dedicated to dealing with lyme disease, together.
Join This Group
Group Home   Forums   Articles   Members (7839)   Diaries   Leaders   Guidelines
Lyme Group RSS Feed
Lyme Disease ForumsGeneral & SupportMy MD refuses to trust my Igenex lab results
10/19/2010 12:21 AM
sandiegolymer
sandiegolymer
 
Posts: 208
Member

I was in Northern California when I had another doctor order my Lyme test thru Igenex labs.

When I returned home to Southern California, I made an appt with my primary doctor who I've been seeing for 15 years and I really like and trust.

My Igenex Lab tests came back and they were positive for Lyme - both the Western Blot and PCR test.

In fact, a week later, the Humboldt County Public Health Dept called me and said "we see that you tested positive for Lyme and we'd like to ask you a few questions."

(They wanted to know if I had the Bullseye Rash - which I didn't. Although I did remember a giant "bruise" on my leg which was really strange - but unfortunately I didn't take a picture of it)

My Primary admitted that he didn't know much about Lyme but would do some research.

At my next appt, he told me that Igenex tests were too sensitive and may not be reliable. He also made a point about them being a "private" lab vs. a non profit?

I've now had TWO LLMD's tell me that I'm Lyme positive and to my Primary's credit - he did put me on 2 months of Doxycycline which he said were medical standard for treatment.

After 2 months, I still wasn't any better - if anything, I was getting worse.

I am now being treated by an LLMD but want to keep my Primary in the loop. He's a very good doctor and he has been doing research on Lyme - however, he is very conservative and only goes by peer reviewed, published medical studies.

I can appreciate this, but every study I send to him about Lyme treatment, he says is either too old or not valid.

How can I find information about Igenex and Lyme treatment that he would consider valid?

(P.S. he has been great about trying to help me with my symptoms, such as nerve pain by prescribing Neurontin, etc.,)

broke up longer paragraphs for us neuro folks, emphasized as needed. bettyg, iowa leader Smile

Post edited by: Bettyg, at: 10/19/2010 12:54 AM

Post edited by: sandiegolymer, at: 10/19/2010 09:11 PM

IgM Western Blot
41 +
83-93 IND

IgG Western Blot
31 ++
34 +
41 +
58 +

PCR Serum Test: Positive for B. Burgdorferi

"Most of the important things in the world have been accomplished by people who have kept on trying when there seemed to be no hope at all." -Dale Carnegie
Reply

10/19/2010 01:07 AM  Top
Bettyg
 
Posts: 26641
VIP Member
I'm an Advocate

hi sandie Smile

typical reaction i'm sorry to say which we hate it; here's several things for you to try ok Smile

read tincup's explaination to lymeseek on IGENEX testing and the background of company! outstanding!

http://flash.lymenet.org/ubb/ultimatebb.php/topic/1/79309

i don't know if above has an actual letter written by someone saying they have top standards, etc. can't find what i want at my finger tips right now.

***************

dr. brian fallen had info published in PUBMED on long-term antibiotics. you might try finding that link in pubmed.

brian's ceo of usa's 1st LYME/TICK-BORNE RESEARCH LAB AT COLUMBIA UNIV, NYC

now idsa, infectious disease society of america, has patents/grants, a real monopoloy of tests and what is published and not published.

you're in the LYME WAR of 2 treatments: idsa, infectious drs.

vs.

ilads, intl lyme associated disease society aka our chronic LYME LITERATE MDS, LLMDS

idsa is recoginized by cdc; our ilads docs aren't.

health insurance goes by cdc; thus will NOT REIMBURSE us for our appts, treatments, labs, meds, etc.

please get THE BAKER'S DOZEN, LUNATIC FRINGE, JUNK SCIENCE BY PJ LANGHOFF, released last year....all about idsa infectious drs. saying 1 thing; doing another with over 1000 links of PROOF of what has been happening to lyme/co-infection community!

show him UNDER OUR SKIN lyme documentary; you can buy it at underourskin.com site or get from libraries.

that's what i can think of at this hour sandie, good luck!

if it's a recent bite, 3 MONTHS OF ANTIBIOTICS; 2 MONTHS SHOWING NO SYMPTOMS BEFORE STOPPING ANTIBIOTICS or you will end up with chronic lyme like the rest of us! Angry

BettyG, IOWA ACTIVIST
RETIRED llmd coordinator of 6 yrs; group leader

NOTE: I DO "NOT" USE CHAT thanks!
**************************************

NO INFORMATION SHOULD BE CONSIDERED MEDICAL ADVICE.
please see my WELCOME LETTER/BEGINNER'S LINKS with important links/info galore :)

http://www.mdjunction.com/forums/lyme-disease-support-forums/general-support/2356916-bettygs-welcome-letter-wgood-beginner-links-

Any information provided should not be used to take the place of advice from your personal physician or other professional.

Information on those sites is the opinion of those who publish the sites and is NOT necessarily that of BettyG.

43 yrs. chronic lyme; 35 yrs. misdiagnosed by 40-50 drs. unacceptable; see my profile for more.

10/19/2010 03:49 PM  Top
sandiegolymer
sandiegolymer
 
Posts: 208
Member

Hi BettyG! Thanks so much for your very informative reply!

Also thanks so much for re-formatting my post - i have to admit - it's even easier for ME to read it now! You're good at this! Smile

I will definitely check out the links you sent. BTW - i DID give my doctor a copy of Under Our Skin and he said he would watch it! I won't know until my next appt if he actually did - but I have hope!

I believe I was bitten in December of last year with symptoms showing up in January. I didn't start the antibiotics until 8 months of being sick and arthritis had already set in by this time. Was also starting to get horrendous nerve pain.

Now that I've tried my PD's method (2 months of Doxy - 100 mg 2 x per day) and nothing happened, I'm now back on my LLMDs method which is to start out with 200 mgs of Doxy 2 x per day plus Flagyl (which my PD didn't agree with) After a few weeks, my LLMD will add additional abx. So i'm crossing my fingers!

Thanks again BettyG for your help! Smile - "Sandie"Smile

Post edited by: sandiegolymer, at: 10/19/2010 03:52 PM

used quotes to enlarge text for neuro lyme patients like me. bettyg, iowa leader Smile

Post edited by: Bettyg, at: 10/19/2010 11:05 PM

IgM Western Blot
41 +
83-93 IND

IgG Western Blot
31 ++
34 +
41 +
58 +

PCR Serum Test: Positive for B. Burgdorferi

"Most of the important things in the world have been accomplished by people who have kept on trying when there seemed to be no hope at all." -Dale Carnegie

10/19/2010 04:07 PM  Top
lindaca
 
Posts: 1009
Member

If your MD is not going to help with proper lyme treatment, use him as a backup in case you have symptoms or side effects that you're concerned about. Your LLMD can prescribe all that you need and give you standing lab orders for required blood tests.

10/19/2010 06:07 PM  Top
waxby
waxbyPosts: 4129
VIP Member

~~~Hello sandiegolymer,

~~~RE your "My MD refuses to trust my Igenex lab results" When it comes to Lyme Disease,refuse to trust your MD.

~~~Twelve years ago my MD ruined my "normal" life! I found the tick and the tick bite.It was a nickel sized raised scabbed welt.

~~~He said it was not a bullseye rash.I said not everyone bitten gets one.He said OK we can test you.I said not every test shows positive.He said if your test shows negative,which it did,two weeks after that test we can do another.It also "showed negative."

~~~Back then I did not know any more than that and that a "negative" test could actually show positive depending on who looks at it.

~~~After a million negative other tests he sent me to an IDDr.Next mistake.She sent me for a million other negative tests and three more "negative" Lyme tests.By the time she decide to put me on abx,after ruling every thing else on the planet out,a year and a half had passed.Way too late!

~~~After six months and no relief I found a LLMD and he with a sixth Lyme test he clinically diagnosed me with Lyme Disease and treated for a year and a half with dozens of pharmeceuticals and still with no relief.Very long story short.

~~~Your Dr is staring at positive Lyme Disease test and is skeptical? Educated Idiot! ~~~RUN FORREST RUN! When it comes to Lyme Disease get away from him and don't look back!

```````~~~from my straight jacket~~~out on a limb~~~lookin like a cocoon~~~hangin by a thread~~~waitin for a butterfly~~~under the moon~~~Lovey-Dovey,Mitchell~~~

Post edited by: waxby, at: 10/19/2010 06:13 PM

~~ "The way to 'Heaven' is to bring it with you ..." -Mitchell
~~ "Sometimes, we gotta go through hell to get to 'Heaven'" -Mitchell
~~ "The way out is in" -Mitchell
~~ "A miracle speaks ...'I don't believe in Miracles.' " -Mitchell
~~ "Life is good, even when it isn't." -Mitchell
~~ "Sometimes you gotta lose to win." -Mitchell
~~ "It's easy when it's easy! Find reason, purpose and meaning when it's hard!" -Mitchell
~~ "If you're gonna think, think again!" -Mitchell
~~ "Make it so!" ...
~~ “When life do what it do, as it do-do, simply say ‘Of Course!’ (to soften life’s ‘blows’)” - Mitchell
~~ A master once said, "When embarking on the spiritual path, 'Oh Dear! There's no turning back! You've really done it now!' "
~~ “Not thoughts be your guide, rather, guide your thoughts.” -Mitchell
~~ "That which is within, and that energy entering this body/mind/spirit, causing harm and ill health, must and will be transformed into love healing energy and sent out in every direction" -Mitchell
~~ One morning ten years ago I awoke from a dream chanting over again and again, and writing this down so as not to forget ... "It doesn't matter who did what, there's nowhere else to go but up ..." -Mitchell
~~ "This life, our life, and what we do with it on this planet is “simply” a display, a reflection, of what is going on in our consciousness. The proof is in the puddin’. Look at our planet, what humans are doing to it, and with it, and to one another, and ask yourself ... ~ 'How’s this working for us/me?' ” -Mitchell
~~ "Step away from monkey mind, not tangle ... Observe ... Inhabit your higher self ..." -Mitchell
~~ "Anything is possible, but manythings you think are true, are not ... " -Mitchell
~~ "Grow where you are planted ..." -Mitchell
~~ "Change your future now ..." -Mitchell
~~ “Write your equation … 4 u r the sum of u … “ -Mitchell
~~ “We are largely a product of our environments … how’s your inner environment doing? …” -Mitchell

10/19/2010 06:59 PM  Top
mbenedette
mbenedettePosts: 2
New Member

I'm in medical school now, and we are literally taught zilch about Lymes disease. I appreciate how you would like to educate your doctor about this, and how he is willing to read things, but the bottom line is that HE is responsible for his education. NOT YOU.

You need appropriate treatment. If he has a patient with something he doesn't get, it's HIS responsibility to find materials that HE believes are suitable.

Looking at the breadth of knowledge available though, not everyone can know it all about one subject. He may be a fabulous PCP, but you definitely need a specialist's management. Good for you for getting appropriate help.


Previous discussions I participated in:
Positive Thoughts for Tomorrow

10/19/2010 07:40 PM  Top
waxby
waxbyPosts: 4129
VIP Member

~~~Hello mbenedette,

~~~It is hard for all of us Lyme Patients to believe,in this day and age,with all that is now known about Lyme Disease,that every Dr,and medical school,on the planet has not been allerted and made aware of the seriousness of this disease.

~~~And any one coming to them with suspected Lyme Disease,pointed to by the vast array of symptoms and "only partially" positive Lyme tests,and so considered negative,

but should be considered at least suspect,should be immediately sent to a specialist,a LLDr(Lyme Literare Dr),who should not be persecuted for dealing with a clinically "clear" portrait of Lyme Disease,

and should be completely supported by the medical community as highly respected, valued, and important specialists in the field of Lyme Disease,just as any one suspected of having cancer is sent to a specialist.

```````~~~from my straight jacket~~~out on a limb~~~lookin like a cocoon~~~hangin by a thread~~~waitin for a butterfly~~~under the moon~~~Lovey-Dovey,Mitchell~~~

Post edited by: Bettyg, at: 10/19/2010 11:09 PM

~~ "The way to 'Heaven' is to bring it with you ..." -Mitchell
~~ "Sometimes, we gotta go through hell to get to 'Heaven'" -Mitchell
~~ "The way out is in" -Mitchell
~~ "A miracle speaks ...'I don't believe in Miracles.' " -Mitchell
~~ "Life is good, even when it isn't." -Mitchell
~~ "Sometimes you gotta lose to win." -Mitchell
~~ "It's easy when it's easy! Find reason, purpose and meaning when it's hard!" -Mitchell
~~ "If you're gonna think, think again!" -Mitchell
~~ "Make it so!" ...
~~ “When life do what it do, as it do-do, simply say ‘Of Course!’ (to soften life’s ‘blows’)” - Mitchell
~~ A master once said, "When embarking on the spiritual path, 'Oh Dear! There's no turning back! You've really done it now!' "
~~ “Not thoughts be your guide, rather, guide your thoughts.” -Mitchell
~~ "That which is within, and that energy entering this body/mind/spirit, causing harm and ill health, must and will be transformed into love healing energy and sent out in every direction" -Mitchell
~~ One morning ten years ago I awoke from a dream chanting over again and again, and writing this down so as not to forget ... "It doesn't matter who did what, there's nowhere else to go but up ..." -Mitchell
~~ "This life, our life, and what we do with it on this planet is “simply” a display, a reflection, of what is going on in our consciousness. The proof is in the puddin’. Look at our planet, what humans are doing to it, and with it, and to one another, and ask yourself ... ~ 'How’s this working for us/me?' ” -Mitchell
~~ "Step away from monkey mind, not tangle ... Observe ... Inhabit your higher self ..." -Mitchell
~~ "Anything is possible, but manythings you think are true, are not ... " -Mitchell
~~ "Grow where you are planted ..." -Mitchell
~~ "Change your future now ..." -Mitchell
~~ “Write your equation … 4 u r the sum of u … “ -Mitchell
~~ “We are largely a product of our environments … how’s your inner environment doing? …” -Mitchell

10/19/2010 08:01 PM  Top
wlkthlne
wlkthlne
 
Posts: 1605
Senior Member

waxby,,,You said that so perfect. The part I like best is how you mentioned "one who has cancer is sent to a specialist"

Absolutly! So why not lyme....LLMD!

I have found and seen several medical people on here.

RN's....medical staff..they now have Lyme..

Each one has said...wow..if only I was tought and knew about this disease...

You can't educate someone who already knows everything.....time to move on...(different Doc)

Anything I post or respond to comes from a Lyme and Bart victim himself. I am NOT a doctor. I do my own research for ME...I may share my findings and will post them. They are for general talk and vent...If a group leader feels the info is worth saving somewhere, they are more than welcome to do with it as they like. Wlk=)

10/19/2010 11:36 PM  Top
Bettyg
 
Posts: 26641
VIP Member
I'm an Advocate

mbenedette

10/19/2010 06:59 PM

Posts: 2

New Member

I'm in medical school now, and we are literally taught zilch about Lymes disease.

reply: with all due respect, here are my thoughts on your post here. 1st we have LYME with no s on end disease named after LYME, CONN.

the dr. may be responsible for their education, but i disagree with you since i was misdx for 35 yrs. out of my 41 yrs. ok!

when we know more than the dr. who has gone for years for big bucks; then we need to educate them taking our "evidence".

again, it may be THEIR responsibility to find the answers for our illnesses, but since we are being HERDED in there like cattle for our 5-10 min. max; it's OUR responsibility as a patient to get OUR MONEY'S WORTH by educating them with their pubmed info, etc.

I appreciate how you would like to educate your doctor about this, and how he is willing to read things, but the bottom line is that HE is responsible for his education. NOT YOU.

You need appropriate treatment. If he has a patient with something he doesn't get, it's HIS responsibility to find materials that HE believes are suitable.

Looking at the breadth of knowledge available though, not everyone can know it all about one subject.

He may be a fabulous PCP, but you definitely need a specialist's management. Good for you for getting appropriate help.

reply: my wish is you'll become a LLMD to share your knowledge and 1st hand experiences with all your patients honoring the DO NO HARM TO PATIENTS.

now i'm off my soap box Smile thanks for sharing your thoughts and allowing me to share mine also. hugs /quote]

BettyG, IOWA ACTIVIST
RETIRED llmd coordinator of 6 yrs; group leader

NOTE: I DO "NOT" USE CHAT thanks!
**************************************

NO INFORMATION SHOULD BE CONSIDERED MEDICAL ADVICE.
please see my WELCOME LETTER/BEGINNER'S LINKS with important links/info galore :)

http://www.mdjunction.com/forums/lyme-disease-support-forums/general-support/2356916-bettygs-welcome-letter-wgood-beginner-links-

Any information provided should not be used to take the place of advice from your personal physician or other professional.

Information on those sites is the opinion of those who publish the sites and is NOT necessarily that of BettyG.

43 yrs. chronic lyme; 35 yrs. misdiagnosed by 40-50 drs. unacceptable; see my profile for more.

10/20/2010 07:55 AM  Top
bips
bips
 
Posts: 148
Member

Bettyg, I can't understand who wrote the above but I just wanted to point something out. I think I said something similar in my first few posts here.

Lyme's is actually a correct way to say it. Lyme's disease. It is an eponym. Just the same way Down's syndrome is named after Dr. Down.

Two other things: In truth, I don't care how people say it as long as they are talking about it.

I am a medical transcriptionist and the place I work for has adopted a style guide where we are supposed to now write Down syndrome (no 's when placed with the word syndrome or disease, that kind of thing) but "Down's" (or Lyme's or any other hundreds of eponyms) when alone : "The patient has Down's." "The patient has Lyme's."

So that is medical documentation. In speaking and anywhere else people want to, Lyme's disease, Lyme's, Lyme disease, Lyme ... they are all correct enough.

Or as I like to call it : HELL. SmileW00t

One last little note, if you would be giving a speech, the totally absolutely correct term for speaking would be the eponym: Lyme's disease.

People all around the country do not take one little medical terminology style guide as rule. Correct grammar would be the case here.

So, not to make a big deal but I would hate to see people told they are wrong when they say Lyme's disease because that is not true.

And this is the one thing I am an expert in Smile that and chocolate chip cookies, so I take my opportunities to speak out when I actually know something. It is so exciting!

Post edited by: bips, at: 10/20/2010 08:09 AM

Post edited by: bips, at: 10/20/2010 08:11 AM

Follow your dreams---except that one where you are walking around in your underwear.
Reply

Health Topics:
Share this discussion with your friends:
Members who viewed this page also read:
<< Start < Prev 1 2 3 Next > End >>

LymeLyme Disease ForumsGeneral & SupportMy MD refuses to trust my Igenex lab results

Disclaimer: The information provided in MDJunction is not a replacement for medical diagnosis, treatment, or professional medical advice.
In case of EMERGENCY call 911 or 1.800.273.TALK (8255) to the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline. Read more.
Contact Us | Bookmark Us | FAQ | Awareness Ribbons
About Us | Terms & Conditions | Privacy | Spread the Word | MDJ Advocates | Advertise
Copyright (c) 2006-2013 MDJunction.com All Rights Reserved