MDJunction - People Helping People
 

Why wear a ribbon?

 
"for my husband, Shane" (marribeth1)

MDJunction to me

joanne82"MDJunction means to me - A family away from family, somewhere I can go
to talk how I feel and be supported. I love to talk to people who
understand how I feel and are going through what I am. I have gained
many friends at MDJunction who I truly care about
" (joanne82)

more testimonials
Depression Support Group
A community of patients, family members and friends dedicated to dealing with Depression, together.
Join This Group
Group Home   Forums   Articles   Members (4003)   Diaries   Videos   Leaders   Guidelines
Depression Group RSS Feed
Depression ForumsGeneral & SupportIs depression a disease or a choice?
07/09/2012 05:43 AM
cinny58
cinny58
 
Posts: 1444
Senior Member

Hey Patty, enjoy the beautiful day. I am under the weather today. Been in bed since early last night. Going back there in a few minutes. Hope you are feeling better today. I know what you mean by feeling trapped. I feel like I can't even get out of my own body. I will just suck it up and move on today. Hope you have a wonderful day.
Reply

07/09/2012 06:04 AM  Top
Peace77
Peace77
 
Posts: 5499
Group Leader

Cindy..Why would you think you can get out of your own body..LOL

Your funny...My cold will just have to come with me today..LOL

Hugs, Patty

Love and Peace, Patty

"If you planted hope today in any hopeless heart, If someone's burden was lighter because you did your part, If you caused a laugh that chased a tear away, If tonight your name is mentioned when someone kneels to pray, Then your day was well spent."

Previous discussions I participated in:
Suprised
We Got Rain This Afternoon!!!
Hi everyone

07/09/2012 09:52 AM  Top
bits
bits
 
Posts: 10322
VIP Member

I think it is both.

I think being able to identify which one it is holds the great possibility of having a good life.

I think one plays upon the other. Thus, causing confusion on treatments.

Let's just say you are living in an unhappy arrangement. It is beyond hard but you keep on because you are really too afraid to change to the unknown.

So, you take all the meds and do all the therapy given...yet they are not working.

Could it be the correct treatment should have been to change the unhappy lifestyle?

To actually change your entire life?

On the other hand, you are living a what should be wonderful life. Great family, friends, spouse, children, finacial security...yet...something is missing.

There is a restlessness in you, an uneasiness, a sadness, and you just can't figure it out.

So you try the meds and happily somewhere along the line it works. This is certainly chemical depression. And all the lifestyle changes in the world will probably not help it very much since it truly is a biological deficent.

Ok, we have established the 2 types depression.

What now?

All areas must be addressed in order to have a healing. By addressing only one then...well, we are still half way sick. And depression can make us feel very badly.

Honesty must be brutal. We may not be wanting to face the changes we need to make or it may be a chemical problem and meds are needed probaby for the rest of our lives.

The hardest is when the 2 are entwined. As, they very often are.

This is simply my opinions on past experiences with self and loved ones.

Depression is real, but we are fighters...all the way.

hugs

When I stand before God at the end of my life, I would hope that I would not have a single bit of talent left, and I could say, "I used everything you gave me." ~ Erma Bombeck
bits

07/09/2012 12:24 PM  Top
Sylvia4648
Sylvia4648
 
Posts: 5136
Group Leader
I'm an Advocate

Hi all. I believe that there has to be some gene or something that causes one person to find after a horrible experience but does not affect someone going thru the same situation. Tho there are certain things that can cause depression in someone who's been happy go lucky, and generally, in some cases. And I do believe there can be remission when one's life is going well. I know because I've gone thru many bouts triggered by something that I might not have even seen before that first dose of deperssion. But I have a friend whose wife is seriously ill. Her medical costs per year are to a middle class worker what the national debt is to the US. He not only runs her errands, does the shopping and most of the cooking, and in between, he sometimes works 10 hours a day. And w/ all of that, if I really need something and my other 'helpers' aren't around, he'll stop what he's doing to help me. I rarely call him for those kinds of things.

The point is, I've never seen a man w/ a seriously sick wife, a job that requires so many hours, home chores, etc., and can still find an hour or so to help a friend. I believe he did not grow up in a family of depressives. I believe he simply doesn't have the disease or his reactions to everything would be different.

But as I said before, once you've got it, you've got it, tho if it was a one-off due to something very visible and obviously the trigger, if that situation could be 'fixed', he may never feel depressed again.

Ciao,

Sylvia

'I didn't have time to write a short [post].' Mark Twain wrote that one for me. LOL
'Wisdom is knowing when you can't be wise.'
'Life is what's happening while we are busy making other plans.'

NOTE: I can't imagine anyone is surprised that distracted driving has overtaken drunk driving as the number one cause of death on the road. Please, y'all, keep your eyes sharp when you drive. The guy in the next car could be on a computer in the dash board (whoever dreamed that up should have to watch autopsies), while the one behind you is texting. It's important to be aware of those around you. The kid who ended my second to last life was in a huge SUV and on the telephone.

I am not a medical practitioner. I speak only from personal experience. Please do not interpret anything I say as medical advice.

07/09/2012 09:20 PM  Top
AsianGoddess

wow! That's a lot of great feedback and insight from everybody. Thanks! I will try to reflect on them tomorrow. I'm not feeling too good right now, stomach ache and nausea. Will get back to everybody tomorrow, though.
Reply

Share this discussion with your friends:
Members who viewed this page also read:
<< Start < Prev 1 2 Next > End >>

DepressionDepression ForumsGeneral & SupportIs depression a disease or a choice?

Disclaimer: The information provided in MDJunction is not a replacement for medical diagnosis, treatment, or professional medical advice.
In case of EMERGENCY call 911 or 1.800.273.TALK (8255) to the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline. Read more.
Contact Us | Bookmark Us | FAQ | Awareness Ribbons
About Us | Terms & Conditions | Privacy | Spread the Word | MDJ Advocates | Advertise
Copyright (c) 2006-2013 MDJunction.com All Rights Reserved