MDJunction - People Helping People
 

Why wear a ribbon?

  "Bipolar II" (sirensong)

MDJunction to me

twistedDNA"MDJunction is an opportunity to share my experiences and understanding with others. No one can understand like someone who's been through it.
My experiences can make a difference in someone else's life.
" (twistedDNA)

more testimonials
Bipolar Support Group
A place where supportive bipolar members, family and friends come to share their ideas and insights.
Join This Group
Group Home   Forums   Articles   Members (11036)   Diaries   Videos   Leaders   Guidelines
Bipolar Group RSS Feed
Bipolar ForumsGeneral & SupportWould you see a therapist who is bipolar?
06/19/2011 06:12 AM
psyd2b
psyd2b  
Posts: 1
Member

So, I had this conversation with someone the other day and thought it would be fun to throw this question out to the group..... Would you go to a therapist who is bipolar (managed, not symptomatic, of course)? And why or why not? Wink

BTW - I'm new at this, so please forgive any faux pas as to where/what/how to post. I'm just a newbie trying to make new friends and get involved in the community. Sideways

Thanks!

Post edited by: psyd2b, at: 06/19/2011 06:28 AM

Reply

06/19/2011 07:11 AM  Top
pirateprincess421
pirateprincess421  
Posts: 31179
VIP Member

I personally would not. But it is hard to tell when you meet a person. I think if I started noticing signs of trouble (cancelled appts), I would be concerned. But I wouldn't put up with that from any therapist.

They of course are not going to tell you. That would be unprofessional.

Princess Lainey

Lamictal 200mg
Risperdal 1.5mg
Trazadon 100mg
Klonapin 1mg
Lexapro 20mg
Wellbutrin 150mg

PS...I hate the snow

Please note that I am not a psychiatrist or psychologist. My opinions are personal only. This site is not intended to be a substitution for professional care, nor is anyone here qualified to make diagnoses.

06/19/2011 07:25 AM  Top
capecod84
capecod84  
Posts: 1820
Senior Member

How would you know? Most doctors cancel appointments. I personally don't want to judge anyone because I sit here and cry miserably when people judge me. I think if the person holds the license they must hold a certain skill set we do not despite the illness. What matters most is can this person help you? They may not fit you, but the next person they may do wonders for. Alot of people in the profession do have some form of mental illness. I personally don't care as long as my paperwork gets processed.
My experience is no substitute for sound medical advice.

Previous discussions I participated in:
Sexual Abuse Allegations
Dream's?
Do you ever......

06/19/2011 07:32 AM  Top
pirateprincess421
pirateprincess421  
Posts: 31179
VIP Member

My doctor has NEVER canceled on me. Once she changed my time an hour later. That's what I mean by professionalism. If someone is having an episode they would be not able to handle their daily functions. Im sure there are great therapists out there with BP or other diseases. But my point is the professionalism.
Princess Lainey

Lamictal 200mg
Risperdal 1.5mg
Trazadon 100mg
Klonapin 1mg
Lexapro 20mg
Wellbutrin 150mg

PS...I hate the snow

Please note that I am not a psychiatrist or psychologist. My opinions are personal only. This site is not intended to be a substitution for professional care, nor is anyone here qualified to make diagnoses.

06/19/2011 07:45 AM  Top
Sparkerama

I would view it as an asset, but it is one of many things I would consider.

06/19/2011 10:21 AM  Top
sarahtroy
sarahtroy  
Posts: 12563
Group Leader
I'm an Advocate

psyd2b, Great question! Welcome to MDJ. This is a very encouraging, supportive and informative group. If you have any questions, please feel free to send a private message (PM) to me or any other group leader.

Now for my answer to your question: Yes, I would consider seeing a bipolar therapist. My feeling is it might make them more compassionate and empathic. But I would not pick a therapist just because they were bipolar. In other words, bipolar is OK, but it is just part of the total picture I'd consider.

Bipolar II, Generalized Anxiety Disorder, Panic Attacks, Agoraphobia & PTSD; Alcoholic in recovery since 3/21/07.

Aplenzin 522mg; Pristiq 200mg; Lamictal 400mg; Geodon 160mg; Ativan 1mg TID; Deplin 15mg; Xanax PRN; Metoprol 100mg.

• "Don't give up 5 minutes before the miracle happens."
• "My little dog - a heartbeat at my feet." ~Edith Wharton
• "Be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a hard battle." ~Ian MacLaren (Usually mis-attributed to Plato)
• "And the day came when the risk it took to remain tight inside the bud was more painful than the risk it took to blossom." ~Anais Nin

My support and advice is not a replacement for medical diagnosis, treatment, or professional medical advice.

Previous discussions I participated in:
Daily Numbers June 19
Mush Brain
Today I am grateful...

06/19/2011 12:28 PM  Top
burtcat
burtcat  
Posts: 105
Member

I wouldn't mind but....of course they wouldn't tell you! I see no reason why it would matter in my opinion though!Smile

Previous discussions I participated in:
Happy Father's Day
Another Night of Good Sleep
Hello

04/17/2012 09:16 AM  Top
invisiblenyc
invisiblenyc  
Posts: 400
Member

Oddly enough, I just found this post while doing a google search for the phrase "I want a therapist who is bipolar".

I've recently been doing research into BP diagnosis and treatment resources in my area and during that process I keep coming back to the notion that I do in fact wish that I could see a therapist who is BP. I am preparing to go in for a consult at a major BP clinic in the area and get to the bottom of whether or not I do in fact have some level of BP. The thing is that based on the way I think, which is an even split between highly regimented thought and highly abstract thought, and my past experiences with 2 different therapists (they were oblivious to the fact that in describing my BP ex's behavior to them that I was describing textbook BP rapid cycling behavior) I keep wondering if a therapist who is not BP is going to be able to connect with me on the intellectual level I need to work on in order to sift through the events with my BP ex, with my BP & PD mother and with all of the insights, memories and connections that during the past 2+ years I've made about behavioral and mood patterns that I've had since I was a kid.

I often say that I think in 4 dimensions. I'm not sure that I'm going to have much luck when I do a google search for a therapist who thinks in 4 dimensions.Blink

I'm still furious at the last therapist I had for telling me that my BP ex's behavior just meant that she was emotionally labile. I get the fact that back then I was dousing the therapist with a ton of info, that I was a bit of a just-beginning-to-heal-from-my-BP-ex mess but still, how does a well established therapist in the global capital of neurotics not recognize classic BP traits when they are put in front of her?

It's ironic/sad that on MDJ I have repeatedly come across members who had/have a partner with BP and who have written about how it was not their therapist who clued them into the fact that their partner/ex likely has BP but that it was a friend or acquaintance who was a social worker or who worked in a mental health facility who told them their spouse/partner likely has BP.

I don't know. I just don't know how I'm going to be able to connect with, relate to a non-BP therapist when I feel as though on a normal day my mind is a cross between a psychedelic lava lamp and an interactive 3D holographic mapping system. Christ, when I'm in public in a bar or cafe and I'm drawing and writing in one of journals it's usually the scientists and/or the clearly BP people who I catch staring over my shoulder at my creations. One guy, who turned out to be a scientist who works on genetic sequencing, said that what I was doing in my journal looked like "data" and what I was doing at the time was a version of my self-portrait.Laughing

Thoughts?

Have a great day!

Post edited by: invisiblenyc, at: 04/17/2012 03:39 PM

"It is important that we remove toxic people from our lives even it is painful for us to do so. If we do not do so then the long-term negative impact of their presence in our lives is often worse than the short-term pain of cutting them out of our lives." - me

"He or she had these problems before you, while he or she was with you, and left untreated will have the problems after you are long gone." - Circles2007

""virtuous personality traits, such as loyalty, empathy and being non-judgemental towards others, can unintentionally act as as emotional "gate way drugs" to becoming co-dependent." - me

"We all have a little of something in us I think. The question is does it prevent you from functioning and leading a productive stable life...if the answer is yes...then your little something is actually a big something that needs to be addressed." - kalissalea

"It's a process, and some days will be easier than others. I can't be with someone who blames me for their behavior. It's too emotionally draining, and prevents us from having the close relationship I deeply want.' - kalissalea

04/17/2012 09:38 AM  Top
LaurenCat
LaurenCat  
Posts: 483
Member

I definitely would! They would be able to relate to m on a personal basis!

04/17/2012 10:06 AM  Top
bob333
bob333  
Posts: 3772
VIP Member
I'm an Advocate

i would if they were fairly stable but the downside is they 2 will b at times struggling with coping with bipolar hence wen u hav lost hope tht therapist will struggle more to install hope in u.
I am Bob, im 23. Please come and check out the bipolar and pregnancy group even if u arent pregnant u may enjoy the comedy section, or if u have previously been pregnant n bipolar u could offer some well needed advice to those of us who r currently going through this life transition.
Reply

Share this discussion with your friends:
Members who viewed this page also read:
<< Start < Prev 1 2 Next > End >>

BipolarBipolar ForumsGeneral & SupportWould you see a therapist who is bipolar?

Disclaimer: The information provided in MDJunction is not a replacement for medical diagnosis, treatment, or professional medical advice.
In case of EMERGENCY call 911 or 1.800.273.TALK (8255) to the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline. Read more.
Contact Us | Bookmark Us | FAQ | Awareness Ribbons
About Us | Terms & Conditions | Privacy | Spread the Word | MDJ Advocates | Advertise
Copyright (c) 2006-2013 MDJunction.com All Rights Reserved